The Mud and Stars Book Blog

thoughts from a girl who spends her days in other worlds…

The ‘cute’ children’s classic that filled me with rage! #rantbookreview

on November 28, 2017

pepp

The Peppermint Pig. Nina Bawden. (First published 1975)

It is a difficult year for the Greengrasses. Poll’s father has lost his job and gone overseas, the family are living off the charity of two aunts, and Poll and her brother Theo just can’t seem to keep out of trouble. It takes a tiny, mischievous pig to bring laughter back into their lives.


I picked up this book because I love pigs and I thought this cosy-looking children’s classic would be the perfect cheer-me-up book. I am not usually one to discourage people from reading a particular book, but if you are an animal lover, vegetarian, or sensitive soul, I would strongly advise you don’t read The Peppermint Pig. I am also not usually one for spoilers, but I am going to spoil the ending of this book in my review/discussion because I need to talk about it and vent my feelings. Look away now, if you don’t want to be spoiled.

So, just to give you a brief idea of why I was so upset by this book, let me give you a synopsis:

  • Children’s dad loses his job. Dad goes off to America to try and make his fortune, leaving the rest of the family to move in with their aunts in a cramped cottage. They do not have much money.
  • Family get a little pet pig called Johnnie who is so small he fits inside a pint glass. Johnnie is a mischievous pig with a penchant for Hot Cross Buns, and cheers the family up with his cheeky antics.
  • Johnnie gets large and fat and too big for the house. Family gets a new puppy to distract the children from what is about to happen.
  • Mum sends Johnnie to the butcher to be slaughtered.

DEAR GOD, WHAT A CRUEL AND BRUTAL WAY TO END A STORY. I had no idea how to rate this book out of five stars, so I ended up giving it no rating at all. I wanted to give it 1 star, but I felt it would be unfair of me to give the book such a bad rating for having a sad ending. But I felt so angry with the author, and even more so with the publishers. Let me explain…

Up until Johnnie is killed, the book had been sweet and lovely and heartwarming. If this book didn’t have such a horrible ending, I might have given it four or five stars for its cosy, charming writing and amusing characters. But I felt incredibly betrayed by this book, because it pretends to be something it isn’t. If I was reading a Stephen King novel, I would expect at least one of the characters to come to a grisly end, because that’s kind of what I signed up for. But, the adorable pig on the front cover and the cutesy blurb on the back cover give no indication that Johnnie is going to end up on someone’s dinner plate by the end of this story. This book is packaged so that it will appeal to animal lovers, yet animals lovers are exactly the kind of audience who should avoid this book like the plague. It all feels so misleading: “Read this cute piggy book, it will make you so happy… oh wait, we’re lying to you, it will actually rip your heart out of your body and spit on it, whilst you sit there and cry a salty river of tears!”

peppermintpig

An even cuter purveyor of evil lies!

I think in some way the author intends for her audience to feel betrayed, because in feeling so we can fully empathise with the little girl protagonist Poll, who loves her friend Johnnie and feels horribly betrayed by her mother for sending him away to be killed and eaten. Perhaps the author is trying to explore the theme of adults lying to/misleading children, and that we cannot always trust those we love. But, the thing is, a few scenes later, the author attempts to justify what has happened to Johnnie by having Poll’s Aunt Sarah take her to the butcher and explain that animals HAVE to be killed so that we can eat them. After this, Poll forgives her mother without much more fuss. So, I’m not really sure what message the author is trying to convey. It doesn’t really seem like she’s on Johnnie’s side though. (RIP)

Don’t get me wrong, I understand why the mum has to sell the pig; I understand that the family are poor and struggling, and that sometimes bad things happen. I know that bad things happening in a book doesn’t make the book itself bad. I know that not all stories have happy endings, and that we shouldn’t shy away from helping children to understand that. But, at the same time… I would never read this story to a child, and I regret reading it myself. Sometimes we NEED a happy book with a comforting ending, to give us hope, to make us feel better. That’s what I thought I was getting, which is the reason I was left so bitterly disappointed by this book.

This is not a bad book, and I can see why lots of people DO love it, because it is well-written, with loveable characters (especially the late Johnnie, RIP). However, this book really wasn’t for me. I’m sorry if this review was an incoherent rant where I repeated myself a bunch of times. I probably could have just typed the word BETRAYAL over and over again and it would have had the same effect. 😛 Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m off to go read something fluffy with a proper happy ending. Recommendations welcome!

P.S. If anyone needs cheering up now, you are welcome to look at this photo of me hanging out with an adorable micro pig (who just would not look at the camera, sorry!) and live vicariously through me 🙂

kewlilpigs


10 responses to “The ‘cute’ children’s classic that filled me with rage! #rantbookreview

  1. honya says:

    Wow, that’s disappointing! Sorry and thanks for the warning.

  2. Ahhh what an awful ending!! I’m sorry you had to read that 😦 I hate when books use animal death or violence for shock value. It makes me feel sick. I’ve read a few books this year with super graphic animal mutilation scenes and they’ve been totally unnecessary to the plot? Like just say they’re hunting and then they did what had to be done. I don’t need 2 pages of descriptive detail.

  3. OH MY GOODNESS WHAT THE HELL!! I’m not a particular pig lover, but even I think that’s seriously messed up to give to children. Like, why would you do that? I didn’t expect that at all!! I’m not sure kids really appreciate *plot twist we killed the cute animal character* either. That’s a bizarre book to give to children. I’m just so shocked to be honest, and yeah I agree with you, I kinda get why other people like it… but also not really cos I find it so weird. I mean, I’m not adverse to dealing with these topics- I loved the movie Babe for instance- but at least he doesn’t actually end up dead! I just think think this seems more like a traumatic read, when yeah, it looks like it’s marketed as something cutesy and sweet. Anyhoo- sorry for the weird rant! I can’t imagine how shocked I’d be if I’d actually read this- pretty shocked at what you said in your review alone. Brilliant review!

    • mudandstars says:

      Thank you! Absolutely – so weird! I don’t think any child would appreciate that ending, it would just unnecessarily upset them. I’m not against including death in children’s books, but it needs to be there for a reason and not for a shock surprise horrific ending. Oh my gosh, I haven’t watched Babe in years, I can’t remember the plot, but I remember loving it when I was little 🙂

  4. oh god this sounds scary for a childs book I definitely wont be giving it to my neice! WHY WOULD THEY KILL OF THE LITTLE PIG!? Is a happy ending not enough, i understand the whole we have to sacrifice for family and monies hard theme but god why not write about a puppy to begin with. Cute little piggy on the cover and everything this would have been devastating. Great rant review ❤

    • mudandstars says:

      Thank you! Exactly! They could have just as easily have explored those themes without having that be the ending. There are so many, less horrific, ways to explore money troubles. It was just toooo sad 😦 I would have hated it even more as a child, I’m sure!

  5. […] Peppermint Pig by Nina Bawden. Whatthedamnhell was that ending?! Read my rant review if you want to know […]

  6. […] Peppermint Pig by Nina Bawden. The ending of this book made me so angry, I wrote a whole rant review about it. It does contain spoilers, but trust me, you’ll be sparing yourself so much unnecessary […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: